For human resources and leaders, finding the right hire between experience and talent becomes a daunting responsibility in today’s phases of shifting talent landscapes. The requirements of skills and experience are advancing the pace of change in the past decades. The companies are now more focused on people’s ability to learn, adapt, and align with the evolving business culture. This vlog explores the dynamics between attitude vs experience, deeper business implications of both terms, and helping leaders to redesign their hiring strategies. 

What is Hiring for Attitude over Experience?

Attitude in the business context refers to giving precedence to the characteristic traits such as ownership, receptiveness to guidance, resilience, adaptability, growth mindset, and solution-driven orientation that will contribute to long-term performance. In high-stake B2B environments, attitude plays a significant role in shaping an individual’s ability to learn, adapt to the culture, resolve conflicts, and embrace challenges in a fast-paced environment. 

Experience becomes an important consideration when the domain of the job role necessitates industry knowledge, expertise, pattern recognition, and such qualities that can solely be achieved through long-duration involvement. Especially on certain competency-focused industries—cyber security, finance, compliance engineering, and roles like operational leadership that demand depth. 

One of the advantages of experience-based recruitment is that the candidates are fit for delivering immediate output with minimal oversight. However, in scenarios like scaling or business transformation, experience alone cannot assure execution stability. There is a common misconception about attitude-based hiring among leaders and recruiters. They commonly assume it’s about neglecting the technical aspect and skill sets. Attitude based sourcing aims to remove the rigid evaluations of conventional recruitment, centered on experience, and instead prioritizes minimum qualification, adaptability, emotional intelligence, and growth mindset as important requirements. 

Attitude vs. Experience: Which Predicts Success Better?

How each Contributes to Performance

Experience ensures accelerated output deliveries, reduced errors, and catalyzes early-stage execution. While on the other hand, attitude based hiring helps determine growth potential, team contributions, and adaptability, integral requirements to navigate in highly complex environments or organizational transitions. 

In essence, when a company focuses on experience, it supports gaining organizational competence but might underdeliver on cultural alignment. Attitude alone might contribute to long-term performance, but risking talent onboarding might take a long duration to attain the desired functional competence. Embracing a combined approach involving both talent and expertise as well as attitude in accordance to the organizational long-term goals and industry will be most advantageous. 

How to Balance Attitude and Experience in Hiring Decisions

1. Build a Role-Specific Hiring Matrix

A hiring matrix should define key competencies, including hard and soft skills, experience level, and behavioral values required for the designated role. Assign the weight of required qualities to improve decision-making. For example, in an industry-specific domain like cybersecurity, the job role demands experience and technical skills more than attitude. While for an entry-level position, prioritizing attitude will contribute toward adaptive learning, innovation, and cultural alignment. 

2. Identify Minimum Qualified Experience

Entrepreneurs should invest in outlining what the necessary qualities are in their hiring checklist. This may include minimum qualification, number of years of experience, paramount technical skills, etc. Avoid setting unrealistic benchmarks and focus on the candidate’s attitude and willingness to learn. 

3. Use Behavioural Interviewing to Test for Attitude

Conducting behavioral analysis tests in interviews to evaluate candidate attitude is highly effective for mapping out their specific expertise, values, and soft skills. Beyond the weight of experience, soft skills, ethics, and attitude toward work life will benefit an organization in the long-term business growth. 

• Ask STAR Questions: The “Star Method” (Situation, Task, Action, Result) can be utilized to prompt questions that explain the past conduct. For example, “Explain about any difficult situation that you dealt with in the past. What steps did you undertake for the successful completion of the project?” 

• Focus on cultural fit and values: Ask questions that reflect the behavioral alignment that resonates with your company culture. 

4. Leverage Practical Assessments to Validate Experience

Conduct practical assessment tests to evaluate the expertise and how much it resonates with the core job functions. These verifications are paramount to validate the authenticity of claims mentioned in resumes. 

How Founders and CEOs Should Rethink Their Hiring Philosophy

• The Long-Term ROI of Attitude-Based Hiring

Attitude fit encourages retention of talent, enhances your organization’s culture, and decreases management challenges. They contribute more than their assigned responsibilities. This characteristic often led them to rise into leadership roles.

By creating a culture that inspires those with a positive attitude, businesses create a strategy for attracting top talent beyond the job description. 

• Build a Culture that Attracts High-Attitude Talent

Talent with a positive attitude will gravitate towards an environment that provides:

1. Autonomy
2. A clear mission with a sense of ownership
3. Safe psychological environment
4. Transparent performance system
5. Empowerment for career development

Organizational culture serves as a filter, both for attitude as well as experience.

• Risks of Over-Indexing on Experience

1. Companies hire corporate profiles, who do not fit within an Agile environment.
2. Hiring system-dependent professionals, who want a highly structured environment and are not capable of creating options.
3. Companies hinder their innovation efforts due to structural rigidity regarding how things have been done in the past.
4. Companies create misalignment within their culture.

Conclusion

In summary, both attitude and experience are paramount in recruitment decisions. Experience-focused hiring contributes individuals with the skills and knowledge to execute their work effectively, while attitude allows for continued growth. The successful organization hires with attitude as the primary driver but adds experience when needed for specific job domains, where accuracy and expertise are nonnegotiable.

To read more visit, EMEA Entrepreneur.